Loading

Test image revised

Trying Ipernity settings, to see if I can limit commenting.

EDIT: Please try commenting if you can.

EDIT (Saturday between 1 and 3 pm local time): Commenting was possible for family and friends for awhile.

EDIT (Saturday evening): Changed the settings again after Mick's (mixpix) comment. Now commenting should be possible only by me. If anyone can comment, then there's something obviously wrong.

EDIT (Sunday morning): I opened commenting again for family and friends.

EDIT (Monday morning): I closed commenting after Evan's post. In this particular case the settings seem to work exactly as it should. However, Evan and I discovered it does not on some other cases. Instead somewhat arbitrary some people seem to be able to comment even if they shouldn't, and some doesn't.

EDIT (Monday evening): I got explanation from Ipernity Team and it turned out very simple. And I was totally wrong. If one contributes within any group with a picture where commenting limited, then members of that group still gets the right to comment. So, if one wants to completely forbid commenting from everyone, then it is not enough to just limit it on settings. Moreover, one should not contribute with that picture in any group. It is only logical. Contributing in a group means you also need to give members of that group the right to give feedback. And therefore that surpasses possible limitation. Those who are not members of that group still can't comment.

Case solved and closed, now everyone can comment this test freely =)

UPDATE 2017: Now testing sharing to Facebook. Read more here: www.ipernity.com/blog/serola/4689426
Visible by: Everyone
(more information)

More information

Visible by: Everyone

All rights reserved

Report this photo as inappropriate

4 comments

Sami Serola (inactiv… said:

Thanks to Evan, we now found out it should work. There is however, maybe a hole in the code. If someone manage to comment before the commenting becomes limited, then that person probably get the permission to do so even after the commenting should be closed.
10 years ago

Sami Serola (inactiv… said:

I opened commenting for family and friends for awhile. Then I changed the settings again after Mick's (mixpix) comment. Now commenting should be possible only by me. If anyone else can comment, then there's something obviously wrong.
10 years ago

.t.a.o.n. said:

test test test :-)
10 years ago

Sami Serola (inactiv… replied to .t.a.o.n.:

Test passed =D
10 years ago ( translate )