Loading
Solarbûn li dijî qirkirinê (Solidarity against Genocide)
Created from Shutterstock Stock Photograph purchased for Article

“You have given up on us. You are leaving us to be slaughtered.”
[1]
[Gen. Mazloum Kobani Abdi, Commander, Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces]

While I oppose any coups, I believe President Trump’s misguided and reckless decision to abandon the Kurds is reason enough for voters to deny him a second term. Personally I cannot in good conscience vote for a President whose actions unleash genocide, nor one who then callously defends them mocking, “The Kurds didn’t help at Normandy.”[2]

Trump’s decision was not “a promise kept” as he claims since troops are still in Iraq whose government is virulently anti-American. Unlike Baghdad’s leaders, the Kurds have proven to be staunch allies who have valiantly defended our interests as well as those of the free world at the cost of more than 11,000 lives in Syria alone agaist ISIS as opposed to America's losses of eight.[3] They also made a Churchillian stand in Iraq and courageously fought ISIS when it appeared the rest of the country was on the verge of total capitulation.

Furthermore, this so-called promise kept breaks a more important one – defeating ISIS since a consequence of abandoning the Kurds has led to the unprovoked Turkish invasion of Syria that he and the world knew was coming based on Erdoğan’s repeated threats, which has resulted in the liberation of thousands of ISIS prisoners enabling them to regroup to fight another day. President Trump alone and no one else is responsible for their newfound freedom.

How about instead of plotting a coup, Congress takes meaningful action and passes a resolution re-committing troops to the Syrian region administered by the Kurds where universal suffrage, freedom of religion and other rights so anathemic to much of that region are present. After all, if members of Congress mean what they say, they should easily pass such a resolution with a veto-proof majority. It could also help the legislative branch regain some of its lost power to “imperial” presidencies that have usurped war-making powers even though Article I, Section 8, Claus 11 of the Constitution “vests in Congress the power to declare war.” Of course, I doubt this will happen since no one in Washington, D.C. has the will or the courage to do what is right.

Just days before President Trump made his ill-advised decision, the Syrian Kurds (YPG) had agreed to pull back all heavy weapons from near the Turkish border and permit a joint US-Turkish presence in an established safe-zone to address Ankara’s national security concerns. Presidents Trump and Erdoğan ignored this gesture since to the latter, his motives were never about Turkish security interests – they were rather about opening a new campaign of genocide this time against the Kurds emboldened by an apathetic world that still ignores their 1914-23 genocide against the Armenians that killed some 1.5 million.

While the Kurds have been left little choice but to align themselves with the Assad regime and Russia, such a move likely will buy them only a little time. If history repeats itself, they too will turn on the Kurds as so many past regimes and allies have when they no longer needed them. Considering the Kurds number about 30 million, it is time the world recognize they deserve a contiguous state (in the parts of Iraq, Turkey, Syria and Iran they inhabit) and work towards such establishment since such a state is the only guarantee the Kurds can be protected against genocide. The United States and an apathetic world will never defend them, proven by their historical examples of mere talk, no action and abandonment when they deem the Kurdish people have outlived their usefulness to their national and political objectives.

Last, even though I have little hope the world will act to stop this new campaign of genocide since international bodies such as the United Nations have consistently looked the other way and avoided use of the term to mitigate their obligations to act – it does bother me, to put it mildly and it is frustrating when innocents needlessly die even if they are in far away lands. During the first two decades of this new millennium – the only glimmer of hope that occurred was when President Obama took quick action to spare the Yazidis from falling victim to genocide when ISIS attempted to exterminate them in the mountainous regions of Iraq.

With a heavy heart and hopes and prayers that things will be different this time despite my skepticism and one day genocide will be a thing of the past, I share three of the photos, I took in Bosnia in 1994 when the genocidal campaign was still raging there, the middle which inspired my poem, “Children of War (©1999):”

The Children of War, so precious and dear,
Stripped of their childhood years, their youth stolen away
Are little saints for human failing through no fault of their own.

The Children of War, their lives lost and scarred,
Are the world’s hopes and future wasted.
They are the cures never found, inventions never made,
Dreams unfulfilled, thoughts and ideas forever gone –
An irrational tragedy, no justification to be found.


Despite the passage of time, these images remain indelibly etched into my memory and I cannot help but protest – “Not again!” since the post Holocaust vow – “Never again!” remains as elusive as ever.

_________

[1] Barbara Starr and Ryan Browne. Exclusive: Military leader of Syrian Kurds tells US ‘you are leaving us to be slaughtered.’ CNN. 12 October 2019. www.cnn.com/2019/10/12/politics/syrian-kurds-us-turkey-military-operation/index.html

[2] Jacey Fortin. Trump says the Kurds ‘Didn’t Help’ at Normandy. Here’s the History. The New York Times. 10 October 2019. www.nytimes.com/2019/10/10/world/middleeast/trump-kurds-normandy.html

[3] Fred Kaplan. Trump’s Worst Betrayal Yet. Slate. 14 October 2019. slate.com/news-and-politics/2019/10/trump-kurds-world-order-betrayal.html

Additional Source:

Kurds pull back as US and Turkey work to establish zone in Syria. The National. 28 August 2019. www.thenational.ae/world/mena/kurds-pull-back-as-us-and-turkey-work-to-establish-safe-zone-in-syria-1.903679


19 comments

©UdoSm said:

I do not want to comment further on this, unless your President is a madman and unpredictable man for the whole world...
This is not only my opinion, but also that of the whole world press...
5 years ago

William Sutherland replied to ©UdoSm:

This misguided action and his refusal to admit he was wrong in the face of genocide definitely gives his detractors ammunition. Thank you Udo.
5 years ago

J.Garcia said:

I understand what you say and i agree with you, William!
But no one wants to admit the existence of a Kurdish nation in such a troubled place in the world.
5 years ago

William Sutherland replied to J.Garcia:

I agree, but part of the reason this part of the world is so troubled is because of the creation of artificial borders that never took into account the various and different ethnic groups. It's kind of ironic there are about 5 million Palestinians in the world and 30 million Kurds yet the creation of a Palestinian state seems more pressing. Is it because touching Turkey, Iran, Iraq and Syria are considered taboo but redefining Israel's borders is not? Hopefully one day there will be consistency and both peoples will have their own states, recognize their neighbors' right to exist and be able to live in peace with their neighbor, be it Iran, Iraq, Turkey, Syria or Israel.
5 years ago

©UdoSm replied to :

Yes William, but "The damage is done" and Trump triggered it...
5 years ago

Don Sutherland said:

What Trump did is "Munich lite." He cruelly betrayed an ally that sacrificed some 10,000 lives fighting ISIS, in part to serve American interests, demonstrated weakness on a historic scale, set in motion an ongoing chain of events that have enhanced the geopolitical position of Russia and Iran, and brought great dishonor onto the United States. This enormous tragedy did not have to happen. It was wholly a matter of deliberate choice. Trump's choice will have profound and adverse consequences that will last well after his Presidency has ended.
5 years ago

William Sutherland said:

I agree Don! Thank you!

One disheartened army officer said it best: “They trusted us and we broke that trust. It’s a stain on the American conscience.[1] One can only wonder, are Japan and Israel next?

[1] Peter Wehner. Trump Betrayed the Kurds. He Couldn’t Help Himself. The Atlantic. 15 October 2019. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/10/trump-betrayed-kurds-whos-next/600004
5 years ago

William Sutherland replied to :

Agreed. The press conference with the Italian President continues to show his lack of understanding, which despite indicators he will win re-election based on Moody's metrics -- will actually cost him the election. If the situation wasn't so sad, tragic and immoral, it would be laughable when Trump called the Kurds "no angels," equated the PKK with ISIS, said their plight "is not America's problem" and took credit for the defeat of ISIS when it was the Kurds who did the heavy lifting and paid the steepest price in blood while we merely supplied weapons and some logistical support.
5 years ago

©UdoSm replied to :

Hi William,
it will take generations to repair or heal the damage that this being called Trump has done around the world - both economically and humanly.
I don't understand the American people, because they allow all this and sometimes they think it's right...
5 years ago

William Sutherland said:

To donate to the Kurdish Red Crescent in Rojava (Syria) one can go to:

www.heyvasor.com/en/banga-alikariye-ji-bo-rojava

Click on the donate button (upper right hand corner) and in the notes section, write "Reference: Rojava."

As many NGOs and charities have pulled out due to the dangers posed by Ankara's genocide campaign, the Kurdish Red Crescent is in urgent need of donations to help Kurdish victims of this unprovoked naked act of agression. I just made a donation myself since it is the least I can do since I am unable to help in any other way.

Not all Americans have abandoned the Kurds even if there isn't much we can do. We stand in solidarity and are grateful for what they have done for our country and the free world for their valiant, courageous and unenviable efforts that no one else wanted to do to defeat ISIS.
5 years ago

William Sutherland replied to :

Udo,

The damage done to the Kurds -- more than 500 lost lives so far, can't be repaired.

You ask why many Americans support Trump. It is because he has been an economic success in the USA with the strongest economy since 1969 and because of his strong support for religious freedom and equally strong opposition to the murder of innocent babies through abortion.

At the same time, I would prefer he negotiates trade pacts with Europe instead of impulsively imposing tariffs, which he was correct to do with regard to China since they repress freedom, exhibit expansionist behavior and engage in unfair trade practices and intellectual property theft), listens to experienced foreign policy advisers to avoid disasters like just happened with the Kurds and most of all STOPPED tweeting.

That said, I still have concerns about his isolationist tendencies and loyalty to allies such as Israel and Japan, and I am not convinced to change my mind to support his re-election bid since the announced five-day pause in fighting, while a positive development, is mere damage control and appears to sole acceptance of Turkey's terms which to me is nothing short of total capitulation and unacceptable. If somehow a fair resolution based on real negotiations and compromise can be reached, other questions remain: How is the damage undone regarding Assad's forces and Russian personnel in the Rojava region of Syria? What is the future of Rojava and will self-governing autonomy and current freedoms and rights including gender equality remain in place? Will a global fund be established with US participation to rebuild damaged areas of Rojava? Will the Turkish border with the Rojava region be reopened to facilitate humanitarian aid and relief services? Will those who executed Kurdish civilians and Kurdish political leader Hevrin Khalaf (1984-2019) be brought to justice and prosecuted for war crimes? I expect nothing less at a minimum to reconsider.
5 years ago

Diana Australis said:

It is horrifying, William. Trump is a mad man. I have just come back from Armenia where the Turks committed the first genocide of the 20th century, by slaughtering over 1.5 million Armenians, a fact which they deny to this day.
I feel desolate for the Kurds.
5 years ago

William Sutherland said:

Thank you for your comment Diana. Hope you had a great trip to Armenia and I'm sure they appreciate the support your tourism has given to their country. Sadly Erdoğan continues to deny the Armenian genocide the Turks had committed, which is a key reason not to trust him and fear Ankara is targeting the Kurds for another round of genocide. Their demand of a 30 mile corridor where the Kurds must leave so Arabs can be settled there clearly meets the standard of ethnic cleansing. I can only hope the Kurds with support from the Syrian army and Russia refuse to leave this area since ethnic cleansing and genocide are never acceptable.

As for President Trump, I believe he may have suffered a breakdown because of the stress caused by the coup attempts against him. There can be no other explanation for his statement, "They had to have it cleaned out"[1] referring to the area the Turks attacked without provocation. George Conway, in spite of being a Trump critic got it right when he said: "Ethnic cleansing, assisted and ratified by the president of the United States."[2] Trump withdrew U.S. forces that gave Turkey clearance to begin ethnic cleansing in Rojava and has made repeated statements defending Turkey's actions and promoted a so-called ceasefire to transform the ethnic demographics of the region based on the withdrawal or removal of the Kurds from the area. Trump has now given reason to consider the 25th Amendment since a mental breakdown as appears to have happened is legitimate reason for removal from office. The only other alternative would be for Vice President Pence and Trump's cabinet to run the affairs of the country and allow him to serve as a figure head "face" of the presidency similar to the way George H.W. Bush and President Reagan's cabinet officials acted when Reagan suffered from Alzheimer's in his second term.

_________

[1] Todd G. Gillman. In Fort Worth, Trump boasts he just saved millions of Kurds by unleashing Turkey, then brokering ceasefire. The Dallas Morning News. 17 October 2019. www.dallasnews.com/news/politics/2019/10/17/in-fort-worth-trump-boasts-he-just-saved-millions-of-lives-by-unleashing-turkey-then-brokering-ceasefire-with-kurds

[2] Mary Papenfuss. In Chilling Echo Of Ethnic Cleansing, Trump Says North Syria Needed To Be ‘Cleaned Out’ Huffpost. 17 October 2019. www.huffpost.com/entry/trump-erdogan-kurds-ethnic-cleansing-syria-ceasefire_n_5da8e1eae4b0bc924759b575
5 years ago

William Sutherland said:

Amnesty International Report:

Documents the 12 October 2019 war crime murder of Kurdish political leader Hevrin Khalef (1984-2019) based on "corroborated witness testimony, verified video footage and [review of] a medical report... 'She was dragged out of her car, beaten and shot dead in cold blood by fighters from Ahrar al-Sharqiya [who]... also summarily killed her bodyguard.'"

The full report about Turkey's war crimes can be found at:

www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2019/10/syria-damning-evidence-of-war-crimes-and-other-violations-by-turkish-forces-and-their-allies

May all these victims rest in peace and their perpetrators be brought to justice for their crimes against humanity and may the world act before any more innocent lives are lost.
5 years ago

Diana Australis said:

I agree with your comments William. I really distrust Erdogan. I have watched him over 16 years become increasingly dictatorial and dogmatic from a religious perspective, moving Turkey further away from the democratic ideal established by Ataturk. I have always felt horror at the Armenian genocide. Being in the country really amplified my feelings. I am sure Erdogan is just up for another land grab and Kurdish Genocide, as the Kurds in Turkey have been subjected to abuse, dispossession and mistreatment for a long time.
5 years ago